Fewer Sales, Stronger Offers: What October Showed in the East Bay
The regional report counted fewer homes sold. The inner East Bay counted higher offers.
A drop in sales is easy to read as a market losing its footing. In October, the Bay Area report put the regional decline at 12.4 percent from a year earlier, and a number like that can sound like a cooling.
Then look at Berkeley. Fifty-two homes sold, down from 59 a year ago, at an average of 137 percent of list price.
Both things are true. A smaller number of sales and a larger premium can show up in the same month, on the same streets, because they measure different things.
What the Regional Report Says
The report attributes the decline in sales to thin inventory, which was 5 percent lower than a year ago, and to affordability limits in some price tiers, with mortgage rates reaching highs not seen in decades. The pressure fell unevenly. Sales of homes under $1.25 million were down 4 percent, and sales between $1.25 and $2.5 million were down 7 percent, with the bulk of those declines in Alameda County, along with San Francisco and San Mateo. At the top, homes sold between $3.5 and $5 million rose 11 percent, and homes above $5 million rose 38 percent. The regional median price reached $1.355 million, up 4.2 percent.
The same report named Alameda County, home to Oakland, Berkeley, and Piedmont, as one of the places with the largest shares of homes selling above asking. So the county that lost the most lower-priced sales was also one of the places where offers over list were most common. A county number can’t explain that. The towns can.
Inner East Bay: Fewer Sales, Higher Premiums
Across the seven inner communities, sales fell 11.1 percent to 287, close to the regional decline. The median price rose 3.5 percent to $1,320,000, and the average list-to-sale ratio reached 122 percent, compared with 113 percent a year ago. It was 122 percent in September as well, which points to a steady level of competition rather than a one-month spike.\
Berkeley’s median rose 12.6 percent from last October to $1,915,000, up from $1,787,500 in September, and homes sold at 137 percent of list, compared with 123 percent a year ago. Oakland shows the report’s affordability point and its competition point at the same time. Sales slipped 5.6 percent to 169, roughly in step with the lower-priced tiers the report described, and the median is $1,062,000. Yet that median rose 8.9 percent, and the average home sold at 119 percent of list, up from 109 percent. Piedmont closed 12 sales, down 25 percent, at a median of $2,950,000, up 8.8 percent, and an average of 128 percent of list. In the city of Alameda, sales halved from 32 to 16 and the median fell 9.3 percent to $1,250,000, yet the average ratio still rose to 111 percent from 108, a reminder that a median and a ratio can tell different stories.
Fewer sales. Higher premiums. That is the pattern the regional report described, visible here in Berkeley, Oakland, and Piedmont.
The Outer Corridor: Prices Moved, Bidding Didn’t
On the surface, the outer corridor looked flat. Combined sales fell 3.7 percent to 157, the median was $1,678,000, up 0.2 percent, and the average ratio was 100 percent, one point above last year. Underneath, the towns moved in different directions.
Orinda’s sales rose 30 percent to 26, and its median rose 15.2 percent to $1,813,250. Walnut Creek’s sales rose 18.2 percent to 39, with a median up 13.5 percent to $1,600,000. Danville went the other way, with sales down 22.9 percent to 37, a median down 5 percent to $1,925,000, and a ratio of 98 percent. Pleasant Hill’s sales fell 13 percent and its median fell 5.6 percent to $1,104,500. Lafayette stayed closest to even, with 29 sales and a median of $1,998,000, down 1.4 percent. Moraga was the only outer town above list, at 104 percent, though on just six sales.
The Orinda and Walnut Creek gains deserve one caution. Orinda’s median was $1,837,500 in September and $1,813,250 in October. Walnut Creek’s was $1,602,500 and then $1,600,000. Neither moved much from one month to the next. Their year-over-year jumps come largely from the comparison point, since last October’s medians were $1,574,375 in Orinda and $1,410,000 in Walnut Creek. A percentage change depends on last year as much as on this year. With ratios at 100 percent in both towns, buyers weren’t bidding prices up. They were meeting sellers at asking.
What This Means Heading Into Winter
If you’re selling in Berkeley, Oakland, or Piedmont, thin supply and ratios between 119 and 137 percent are on your side. They don’t replace a price grounded in the closest recent sales on your own street, and preparation still determines how much of that competition a home actually draws.
If you’re buying in those towns, expect to compete above list. Settling on a ceiling before the offer window opens, using your town’s ratio and not the regional one, keeps the decision from being made under a deadline.
If you’re selling in Danville, Pleasant Hill, or Lafayette, ratios at or near 100 percent mean the first price carries most of the weight. There is little bidding to correct an optimistic number.
If you’re buying in Danville or Pleasant Hill, ratios of 98 and 99 percent suggest some room to negotiate.
Bottom Line
A falling sales count can mean a cooling market or a thin one, and the list-to-sale ratio is often what tells them apart. In October, Berkeley, Oakland, and Piedmont read as thin. Danville and Pleasant Hill read as balanced.
The count tells you how many homes changed hands. The ratio tells you how hard buyers competed for them. October needed both.